Spherical Crystallization:
Novel Technique
Ganesh
S. Bhoi1*, Nayana V. Pimpodkar2
1Lecturer, College of Pharmacy (D.Pharm),
Degaon, Satara (MH) India -
415004.
2Principal, College of Pharmacy (D.Pharm)
Degaon, Satara (MH) India-
415004
*Corresponding
Author E-mail: ganesh.bhoi4596@yahoo.com
ABSTRACT:
Spherical crystallization is the novel agglomerated technique that
can directly transform the fine crystals produced in the crystallization
process into a spherical shape. It is the particle engineering technique by
which crystallization and agglomeration can be carried out simultaneously in
one step to transform crystals directly into compacted spherical form. This
technique of particle design of drugs has emerged as one the areas of active
research currently of interest in pharmaceutical manufacturing and came into
the forefront of interest or gained interest due to the fact that crystal habit
can be modified during crystallization process which would result in better micromeritic properties. Prepared spherical crystals can be
compresses directly without performing granulation, drying and so many steps
those are required in wet granulation and in dry granulation process of tablet
manufacturing.
General methods
of spherical crystallization are spherical agglomeration, emulsion solvent
diffusion, and ammonia diffusion method. The principle steps involved in the
process of spherical crystallization are flocculation zone, zero growth zone,
fast growth zone, and constant size zone. Factors controlling the process of
agglomeration are solubility profile, mode and intensity of agitation,
temperature of the system, and residence time. Spherical crystallization is
having wide applications in pharmaceuticals like improvement of flow ability
and compressibility of poorly compressible drugs, masking bitter taste of drugs
and improving the solubility and dissolution rate of poorly soluble drugs.
KEYWORDS: Spherical crystallization, Agglomeration
technique, Agglomeration.
INTRODUCTION:
Spherical
crystallization is a particle design technique, by which crystallization and
agglomeration can be carried out simultaneously in one step and which has been
successfully utilized for improvement of flowability
and compactability of crystalline drugs. The various
parameters optimized are type, amount
and mode of addition of bridging liquid, temperature, and agitation speed to
get maximum amount of spherical crystals. These were characterized for micromeritic properties (particle size and shape, flow
ability), Packability (bulk density), wettability (contact angle) and compressibility. It was
revealed from the studies that spherical agglomerates exhibited improved flowability, wettability,
compaction behavior and bioavailability.
The oral route
of administration is the most important method of administering drugs for
systemic effects.
In this, the
solid dosage form, particularly, tablets are the dosage form of choice because
of their special Characteristics like unit dosage form with greatest dose
precision and least content variability, lower cost, easy administration by a
patient and temper proof nature. The formation of solid oral dosage forms and
tablets in particular, have undergone rapid changes and development over the
last several decades and one of the most revolutionary technologies is that of
direct compression. It is economical, facilitates processing without the need
for moisture and heat and small number of processing steps are involved The
basic requirement for commercial production of tablet is a particulate solid
with good flowability, mechanical strength and
compressibility. Hence it is necessary to evaluate and manipulate the above
said properties. To impart these properties the drugs are subjected to particle
design techniques. Spherical crystallization is one of the techniques of
particle design. The particle size can be enhanced by the help of wet
granulation method, dry granulation method, extrusion spheronization
and by spherical crystallization methods. The spherical crystallization is a
nonconventional particle- size enlargement technique that involves
crystallization and agglomeration using bridging liquid1.
Steps
Involved In Spherical Crystallization1
Flocculation
Zone:
In this zone the
bridging liquid displaces the liquid from the surface of the crystals and these
crystals are brought in close proximity by agitation, the adsorbed bridging
liquid links the particles by forming bridge or lens between them. In this
zone, loose open flocs of particles are formed by pendular bridges and this stage of agglomeration process
where the ratio of liquid to the void volume is low and air is the continuous
phase, is known as the pendular state. Mutual
attraction of particles is brought about by surface tension of the liquid and
the liquid bridges. The capillary stage is reached when all the void space
within the agglomerate is completely filled with the liquid. An intermediate
state known as funicular state exists between the pendular
and capillary stage. The cohesive strength of agglomerate is attributed to the
bonding forces exerted by the pendular bridges and
capillary suction pressure.
Zero Growth Zone:
Loose flocs get transferred into tightly packed pellets, during
which the entrapped fluid is squeezed out followed by the squeezing of the
bridging liquid On to the surface of the small flocs
causing pore space in the pellet to be completely filled with the bridging
liquid. The driving force for the transformation is provided by the agitation
of the slurry causing liquid turbulence, pellet-pellet and pellet-stirrer
collision.
Fast Growth
Zone:
The fast growth
zone of the agglomerate takes place when sufficient bridging liquid has
squeezed out of the surface of the small agglomerates. This formation of large
size particle following random collision of well formed nucleus is known as
coalescence. Successful collision occurs only if the nucleus has slight excess
surface moisture. This imparts plasticity on the nucleus and enhances particle
deformation and subsequent coalescence.
Constant Size
Zone:
In this zone
agglomerate ceases to grow or even show slight decrease in size. Here the
frequency of coalescence is balanced by the breakage frequency of agglomerate.
The size reduction may be due to attrition, breakage and shatter. The
rate-determining step in agglomeration growth occurs in zero growth zone When bridging liquid is squeezed out of the pores as
the initial flocs are transformed into small
agglomerates.
Methods of Spherical Crystallization1
Figure 1
Solvent
Change Method (SC):
The solution of
the drug in a good solvent is poured in a poor solvent under controlled
condition of temperature and speed to obtain fine crystals. These crystals are
agglomerated in the presence of bridging liquid. The poor solvent has
miscibility with good solvent but low solubility with solvent mixture so during
agitation of the solvent system the crystals are formed. The Drawback of this
system is that it provides low yield because the drug shows significant
solubility in the crystallization solvent due to cosolvency
effect. This method is not applicable for water insoluble drugs.
Quasi
Emulsion Solvent Diffusion Method (QESD):
It involves the
formation of quasi- emulsion of solution of drug in good solvent with a
non-solvent. The crystallization of drug occurs by counter diffusion of good
solvent and poor solvent. Residual good solvent in droplets acts as a bridging
liquid to agglomerate the generated crystals. In this process the emulsion is
stabilized by the selection of suitable polymer which is required for proper
crystallization. In the droplets, the process of solidification proceeds
inwards so the liquid is not maintained on the surface so the agglomerate is
formed without coalescence.
Ammonia
Diffusion Method (AD):
In this method
ammonia water act as a good solvent and bridging solvent, other components of
this method are bad solvent and hydrocarbon/halogenated hydrocarbon (acetone).
The hydrocarbon is miscible with the system but it reduces the miscibility of
ammonia water with bad solvent. The fraction of ammonia water
in the system that exists as an immiscible phase, forms droplet. The
counter diffusion process across the droplet involves movement of bad solvent
into and ammonia out of the droplet. The droplet collects the crystals as a
drug in ammonia water precipitates slowly and growth of agglomerates occurs.
Salting Out
Method (SO):
This method
involves the addition of suitable salt for drug to crystallize out in the
presence of bridging liquid.
Factors Controlling the Process of
Agglomeration2
1.Solubility profile:
The selection of
solvent is dictated by solubility characteristic of drug. A mutually
immiscible three solvent system consisting of a poor solvent (suspending
liquid), a good solvent and a bridging liquid are necessary. Physical
form of product i.e. whether micro agglomerate or irregular macro agglomerates
or a paste of drug substance can be controlled by selection of proper solvent
proportions. The proportion of solvent to be used is determined by
carrying out solubility studies and constructing triangular phase diagram to
define the region of mutual immiscibility by using Ternary diagram.
2.Mode and intensity of agitation:
High speed
agitation is necessary to disperse the bridging liquid throughout the system.
Any change in agitation pattern or fluid flow would be reflected as change in
force acting on agglomerate, which ultimately affects the shape of agglomerate.
The extent of mechanical agitation in conjugation with the amount of bridging
liquid determines the rate of formation of agglomerate and their final size.
3.Temperature of the system:
Study revealed
that the temperature has a significant influence on the shape, size and texture
of the agglomerates. The effect of temperature on spherical crystallization is
probably due to the effect of temperature on the solubility of drug substance
in the ternary system.
4. Residence
time:
The time for
which agglomerates remain suspended in reaction mixture affect their strength.
Need for Spherical Crystallization3
Developing novel
methods to increase the bioavailability of drugs that inherently have poor
aqueous solubility is a great challenge to formulate solid dosage form.
Mechanical micronization of crystalline drugs and
incorporation of surfactants during the crystallization process are the
techniques commonly used to improve the bioavailability of poorly soluble
drugs. The mirconization process alters the flow and
compressibility of crystalline powders and cause formulation problems. Addition
of surfactant generally led to less significant increase in aqueous solubility.
To overcome this problem Kawashima developed a spherical crystallization
technique that led to improving the flow and direct compressibility of number
of microcrystalline drugs.
Advantages of Spherical Crystallization1
· Spherical crystallization technique has
been successfully utilized for improving of flowability
and compressibility of drug powder.
· This technique could enable subsquent
processes such as seperation, flitration,
drying etc to be carried out more efficiently.
· By using this technique, physicochemical
properties of pharmaceutical crystlas are
dramatically improved for pharmaceutical process i.e. milling, mixing and tabletting because of their excellentflowability
and packability.
· This technique may enable crystalline forms of
a drug to be converted into different polymorphic form having better bioavilablity.
· For masking of the bitter taste of drug.
· Praparation of microsponge,
microspheres and nanospheres, microbaloons,
Nanoparticles and micro pellets as novel particulate
drug delivery system.
Evalaution of Spherical Crystals3
As these
spherical agglomerated crystals showing significant effect on the formulation
and manufacturing of pharmaceutical dosage forms so it is necessary to evaluate
them by using different parameters.
Flow
Property:
Flow property of
the material depends on the force developed between the particle, particle
size, particle size distribution, particle shape, surface texture or roughness
and surface area. Flowability of the agglomerates is
much improved as the agglomerate exhibits lower angle of repose then that of
single crystals. Studies on spherically agglomerated aspirin crystals revealed
that, the angle of repose of agglomerated crystals was 31.13 while that of unagglomerated crystals was 47.12.This improvement in the flowability of agglomerates could be attributed to the
significant reduction in inter-particle friction, due to their spherical shape
and a lower static electric charge. Following are the methods used to determine
of flow property
Angle of
Repose:
This is the
common method used for determination of flow property. The angle of repose is
the angle between the horizontal and the slop of the heap or cone of solid
dropped from some elevation. Values for angle of repose ≤ 30 usually
indicate free flowing material and angle ≥ 40 suggested a poor flowing
material. The angle of repose can be obtained from equation
Tan θ = h/0.5d
Where h- height of the cone and d- diameter
of the cone
Compressibility
or Carr Index:
A simple
indication of ease with which a material can be induced to flow is given by
application of compressibility index
I = (1-V/Vo) *100
Where v = the
volume occupied by a sample of powder after being subjected to a standardized
tapping procedure and Vo = the volume before tapping.
The value below 15% indicates good flow characteristics and value above 25%
indicate poor flow ability
Hausner Ratio:
It is calculated
from bulk density and tap density.
Hausner ratio = Tapped density / Bulk density
Values less than
1.25 indicate good flow (20% Carr Index) and the value greater then 1.25 indicates poor flow (33% Carr Index).
Density
Density of the
spherical crystals is the mass per unit volume.
Density = M/V
Porosity:
Porosity of
granules affects the compressibility. Porosities are of two types intragranular and intergranular
and these are measured with the help of true and granular densities.
Intragranular porosity = 1- Granular density /True density.
Intergranular porosity = 1- Bulk density / Granular density
Total Porosity =
1- Bulk density/ True density
Packability:
Improve packability has been reported for agglomerates prepared by
spherical crystallization. The angle of friction, shear cohesive stress and
shear indexes are lower then that of single crystals,
which can improve the packability of the
agglomerates. The packability of agglomerates
improved compared with those of the original crystals and that the agglomerated
crystals are adaptable to direct tabletting. The packability assessed by analysis of the tapping process
with the Kawakita(I) and Kuno(II) method and using
the parameters a, b,1/b, k in the equation
N/C = 1/ (ab)
+N/a..................................................... I
C = (Vo-Vn)/Vo,
a =(Vo-V∞) /Vo.
ρf- ρn= (ρf- ρo) . exp. (-kn)
II
Where, N =Number
of tapping
C =Difference in
volume (degree of volume reduction.) and a, b are constant.
Compression
Behaviour Analysis:
Good compactibility and compressibility are essential properties
of directly compressible crystals. The compaction behavior of agglomerated
crystals and single crystals is obtained by plotting the relative volume
against the compression pressure. Spherical agglomerates possess superior
strength characteristics in comparison to conventional crystals. It is suggest
that the surface are freshly prepared by fracture during compression of
agglomerates, which enhances the plastic inter particle bonding, resulting in a
lower compression force required forcompressing the
agglomerates under plastic deformation compared to that of single crystals. Compaction behaviour
of agglomerated crystals were evaluated by using following parameters
Heckel Analysis:
The following Heckel's equation used to analyze the compression process
of agglomerated crystals and assessed their comapctibility.
In [1/(1-D)]=KP+A
Where:
D is the
relative density of the tablets under compression Pressure
K is the slope
of the straight portion of the Heckel Plot
The reciprocal
of K is the mean yield is the mean yield pressure (Py).
The following
equation gives the intercept obtained by extrapolating the straight portion of
the plots
A = 1n [1/(1-D0)]+B
Where:
D0 is the
relative density of the powder bed when P=0.
The following
equation gives the relative densities corresponding to A and B.
DA = 1-e-A
DB = DA-D0
Stress
Relaxation Test:
In this test put
specific quantity of spherical agglomerated crystals sample in a die specific
diameter the surface of which is coated with magnesium stearate
in advance, then used the universal tensile compression tester to compress the
samples at a constant speed. After the certain limit of pressure attained, the
upper punch held in the same position for 20 min, during which measured time
for the reduction amount of the stress applied on the upper punch. The result
corrected by subtracting from this measurement the relaxation measured without
powder in the die under the same conditions. The following equation finds the
relationship between relaxation ratio Y(t) and time t,
calculated the parameters As and Bs, and assessed relaxation behavior.
t/Y(t) = 1/AsBs-t/As
Y(t) = (P0-Pt)/P0
Where:
P0 is the
maximum compression pressure, and Pt is the pressure at time t.
Mechanical
Strength:
Spherical
crystals should posses good mechanical strength as
that directly reflects the mechanical strength of compact or tablet. It is
determine by using the following two methods
Tensile
strength:
Tensile strength
of spherical crystals is measured by applying maximum load required to crush
the spherical crystal. This method is a direct method to measure the tensile
strength of spherical crystals
Crushing
Strength:
It is measured
by using 50ml glass hypodermic syringe. The modification includes the removal
of the tip of the syringe barrel and the top end of the plunger. The barrel is
then used as hallow support and the guide tube with close fitting tolerances to
the Plunger. The hallow plunger with open end served as load cell in which
mercury could be added. A window cut into the barrel to facilitate placement of
granule on the base platen. The plunger acted as movable plates and set
directly on the granules positioned on the lower platen as the rate of loading
may affect crushing load (gm). Mercury is introduced from reservoir into the
upper chamber at the rate of 10 gm/sec until the single granule crushed;
loading time should be <3 minutes. The total weight of the plunger and the
mercury required to fracture a granule is the crushing load.
Friability
Test:
The friability
of the spherical crystals is the combination of the attrition and sieving
process in to a single operation. Granules along with the plastic balls placed
on a test screen. The sieve is then subjected to the usual motion of a test
sieve shaker provided the necessary attrition on the granules. The weight of
powder passing through the sieve is recorded as function of time. The
friability index is determined from the slop of the plot of % weight of
granules remaining on the sieve as a function of time of shaking.
Friability of
agglomerates determined by using formula
Friability(X) =
{1-W/Wo}/100
Where
Wo = Initial weight of the crystalline
agglomerates placed in sieve
W = Weight of
the material which does not passed through sieve after 5 min.
Particle Size
and Size Distribution:
Size of the
particle and their distributions can be determined by simply sieve analysis.
Now with the help of Ro-Tap sieve shaker, particle size analysis can be
determined. In advance technology image-analyzer is used to determined size and
volume of the particle.
Moisture
Uptake Study:
The study
indicates the behavior of uptake of moisture by drug and the prepared spherical
crystals, which affect the stability. The weighted quantity of drug and
spherical crystals placed in crucible at accelerated condition of temperature
and humidity,40 C ± 10C and 75% ± 3%respectively. The
gain in weight of drug and spherical crystals is measured
Particle
Shape / Surface Topography:
Following
methods are used
· Optical Microscopy:
The shape of the
spherical crystals is studied by observing these under a
optical microscope. The observations are made under the observation like 10X,
45X, 60X etc.
· Electron Scanning Microscopy:
The surface
topography, type of crystals (polymorphism and crystal habit) of the spherical
crystals is analyzed by using scanning electron microscopy.
· X-ray Powder Diffraction:
This is an
important technique for establishing batch-to-batch reproducibility of a
crystalline form. The form of crystal in agglomerates determine by using
technique. An amorphous form does not produce a pattern. The X-ray scattered in
a reproducible pattern of peak intensities at distinct angle (2θ) relative
to the incident beam. Each diffraction pattern is characteristics of a specific
crystalline lattice for a compound.
Applications of spherical crystallization
in pharmaceuticals2
1.To
improve the flow ability and compressibility:
Today the tablet
is the most popular dosage form of all pharmaceutical preparations produced.
From the manufacturing point of view tablets can be produced at much higher
rate than any other dosage form. Tablet is the most stable readily portable and
consumed dosage form. The formulation of tablet is optimized to achieve goals.
The focus today in the business is better drug delivery concepts, but also
makes the simple standard formulations as economical as possible to produce.
One of the most economical solutions is to find directly compressible
formulations and this is especially at interest for large volume products.
2. For masking bitter taste of drug:
Microcapsules
are prepared to mask the bitter taste of the drug. They are suitable for
coating granules, since spherical material can be uniformly coated with a
relatively small amount of polymer. Microcapsules of following drugs were
prepared for masking of
bitter taste. Various drugs of which taste masking has done were
listed in table.
3.For increasing solubility and dissolution rate
of poorly soluble drug:
Spherical
crystallization has been described as a very effective technique in improving
the dissolution behavior of some drugs having low water solubility and a slow
dissolution profile.
Table 1. List of drugs on various spherical
agglomeration technique have been tried for improving physicochemical
properties.
|
Sr.
no. |
Drug |
Method |
Property
improved |
|
01 |
Aspirin |
SA |
Flowability and Compressibility |
|
02 |
Salicylic acid |
SA |
Flowability
and Compressibility |
|
03 |
Aspartic acid |
SA |
Flowability
and Compressibility |
|
04 |
Ibuprofen |
QESD |
Flowability
and Compressibility |
|
05 |
Ampiciline trihydrate |
ADM |
Taste masking |
|
06 |
Norfloxacin |
ADM |
Flowability
and Compressibility |
CONCLUSION:
The spherical
crystallization technique is a simple and inexpensive for scaling up to a
commercial level. It reduces time and cost by enabling faster operation, less
machinery and fewer personnel because it eliminates most of the steps which are
required in granulation technology of tablet manufacturing. The spherically
agglomerated crystals can be prepared into tablet form or compounded directly
into a pharmaceutical system without further processing such as granulation.
REFERENCES:
1. Gupta M, Srivastava B, Sharma M, Arya V. Spherical Crystallization: A Tool of Particle
Engineering for Making Drug Powder Suitable For Direct Compression: Int Jou of Pharma
Research and Development. 2010, 1(12).
2. Patil S, Sahoo S. Pharmaceutical
Overview of Spherical Crystallization: Scholars Research Library 2010: 2 (1)
421-426.
3. Goyal N, Sharma N, Sharma P. Spherical crystallization: A
method for improving powder and tablet characteristics. Scholars Research Library
2010, 2(4), 246-254.
4. Szabo-Revesz P, Hasznos-Nezdei M,
Farkas B, Goczo H. Crystal
growth of drug materials by spherical crystallization. Journal
of Crystal Growth. 2002, 237239.
5. A.R. Paradkar, A.P. Pawar, K.R. Mahadik, S.S. Kadam. Indian Drugs 1994; 6: 229233.
6. Y. Kawashima.
New processesapplication of spherical crystallization to particulate design of
pharmaceuticals for direct tabletting and coating and
new drug delivery systems. In: Powder Technology and Pharmaceutical Processes.
Handbook of Powder Technology, 1994; 9: 493512.
7. Y. Kawashima, M.
Okumura, H. Takenaka. Powder Technol. 1984;
39: 4147.
8. Y. Kawashima, M.
Imai, H. Takeuchi, H. Yamamoto, K. Kamiya, T Hino.
Powder Technol. 2003; 130: 283289.
9. A. Bausch, H. Leuenberger. Int J Pharm. 1994; 101: 6370.
10. A.S. Bos, F.J. Zuiderweg. Chem Eng Res
Des. 1987; 65a: 187.
11. A.F. Blandin, D. Mangin, A. Rivoire, J.P. Klein, JM Bossoutrot.
Powder Technol. 2003; 130: 316323.
12. A. Sano, T. Kuriki, Y. Kawashima, H.
Takeuchi, T. Hino, T. Niwa. Chem
Pharm Bull. 1992; 40:
30303035.
13. Y. Kawashima, F. Cui, H. Takeuchi, T. Hino,
T. Niwa, K. Kiuchi. Int J Pharm. 1995; 119: 139-147.
14. M.K.
Chouracia, A. Jain, S. Valdya,
S.K .Jain. Indian Drugs. 2004; 41 (6), 319-29.
15. P.K. Kulkarni, B.G. Nagavi. Ind. Jr. Pharm. Eudc. 2002;
36(2), 66-73
16. R.F. Shangraw. Compressed tablets by direct
compression. In: Lieberman HA, Lachman L,
Schwartz JB. Pharmaceutical Dosage Forms: Tablets, vol. 1. Marcel Dekker, New
York, 1989; 195246.
17. J.K. Guillory. Polymorphism in pharmaceutical solids. Marcel Dekker, New
York, 1989; 183-226.
18. Y. Kawashima.
Arch Pharm. Res. 1984; 7(2): 145-151.
19. Y. Kawashima, H. Ohno, H. Takenaka. J. Pharm. Sci.
1981; 70(8): 913-916.
20. Y. Kawashima, K.
Furukawa, H. Takenaka. Powder Technol. 1981;
30: 211